There are lots of games from the past that the addition of new features like Online Co-Op or a fleshed out story world make for a terrific buy... but a lot of these games seeking Greenlight offer none of the above.
What is wanted:
- New and original gameplay concepts not done before
- Online Co-Op applied to gameplay concepts that were until now only single-player
- Enhanced (in more ways than just graphics) versions of old games
- A new version of old games that didn't have much in the way of story and this new version has a through and rich story to experience with the tried and tested gameplay.
Here's one thing I found interesting by the way, I voted to Greenlight Miner Wars based entirely on the opening video and game-play videos that were available at the time but after it was released on steam I read a more full review explaining how lackluster it was and that just MADE ME SAD. The backstory for Miner Wars was simply brilliant and would have made it could have made a SCIFI EPIC.
See for yourself in their official launch trailer:
Unfortunately despite the brilliantly written back-story the game-play of Miner Wars fails to stack up. I hope that whoever wrote that looks into having novels produced instead. I have zero doubts that it would become a hit among scifi fans.
But, I got a little off-topic. Greenlight, yes. Several good games have come out of Steam Greenlight but the majority that sit awaiting confirmation are hardly worth my time to click "I'll pass".
In terms of actual Steam Greenlight releases, I recommend having a look at Mc Pixel, DLC Quest, and Organ Trail.
- MC Pixel features new hilarious game-play so off the wall.
- DLC Quest was a stright up satire on modern gaming and did it's job well
- Organ Trail was a fully featured Zombie Conversion to Oregon Trail, and is entirely updated with new features and it's a shining example of: IF YOU ARE GOING TO MAKE A REMAKE WITH A NEW THEME.... THIS IS HOW TO DO IT.